Does accelerating dental treatment accelerate risk?

Estimated read time: 5 min read
Consumer expectations, clinical compromise, and the importance of consent in dentistry.

The impact of consumerism is evident across many areas of our lives - how we eat, how we access information and how we communicate. Perhaps then it is inevitable that people are now approaching healthcare with the same consumer expectations, wanting their treatment quicker, cheaper, more conveniently than before, definitely pain-free and absolutely on their own terms. Naturally, practitioners are striving to meet these demands and expectations. Dr Annalene Weston explores whether in doing so as a profession, we racing to the bottom or rising to the top.

Consumer expectations and the rise of convenience dentistry

There is a raft of direct-to-consumer marketing promising to meet exactly all of a customer’s expectations, and this may be partially responsible for the increased inclination of the profession to do the same. After all 'the public gets what the public wants', and if we as a profession don’t provide it, then our patients will go and find someone who will. But in doing so, are we placing consumer expectations above clinical parameters, and does meeting this demand come with an unseen price? Or perhaps a cost? And if so, to whom?

How accelerated treatment is changing clinical practice

Many disciplines of dentistry are evolving at breakneck speed. Procedures have fewer steps (think bonding) and quicker time frames (think milled restorations), and there are more legitimate options for one-stage procedures than ever before (such as RCT and implants). There can be no doubt that the ability to provide more timely treatments is welcomed by practitioners and patients alike. There can also be no doubt that accelerated treatments are a sensible option for many patients. They are not however without risk.

Convenience dentistry is no longer only available through adverts on Instagram, and is readily seen in everyday practices. Nor is it a new concept. Immediate dentures were in many ways the original mode of ‘accelerated dentistry’ as in this treatment modality. Oftentimes, steps were missed through necessity (as it is hard to try a denture in when the teeth are still in situ) in order to reach an end goal more quickly. Can we extrapolate from this experience that accelerating treatment always means skipping steps? Not necessarily, and if it does, it is important to remember that it does not necessarily mean these steps are skipped in a deleterious way. For example, the ability to scan a tooth to then mill a crown directly – thus skipping a physical impression, a potentially unpleasant or unsatisfactory temporary crown, and the delay whilst the lab constructs the definitive restoration – would not be grieved by many practitioners or patients. 

Regretfully however, immediate dentures do attract a significant amount of dissatisfaction. The patient doesn’t necessarily have the outcome they were expecting, through no fault of the practitioner, partially because the necessary try-in phase is not necessarily missed. Can we perhaps extrapolate then to assume that all accelerated treatments often lead to patient dissatisfaction? This too, does not hold true.

Consent, compromised treatment, and patient understanding

The outcome which patients can legitimately expect needs to be appropriately set as part of the consent process. This is particularly true in accelerated treatment, when the outcome can, in some circumstances, actually be termed as a ‘compromised treatment (although not necessarily obvious to the patient). And while compromised care can be acceptable with patient consent, the key to this acceptability is the consent. The patient needs to meaningfully understand what they are getting, why, and what alternative options exists, applicable in their case. Critically, they also need to be aware of additional costs that may be occurred down the track (think reline). Failure to obtain valid consent, coupled with the failure to meet the patient's expectations, is a true recipe for disaster.

Further, poor case selection can lead to unsatisfactory outcomes, dissatisfied patients, and patient harm. When moving through treatment more quickly, or bypassing stages altogether, a prudent practitioner must ensure appropriate case selection at the offset. This means they avoid finding out later that a one-stage treatment was never going to work for Mrs X, or a compromised outcome was never going to satisfy Mr Y. It also means they can avoid the attention of a critical third party, such as the regulator or a lawyer. 

In short, as with all dentistry, consent is key, as is reaching a correct diagnosis to create an appropriate treatment plan. Each discipline of dentistry carries with it its own unique risks, and, in certain circumstances, accelerating the treatment truly accelerates these risks. The consequences can negatively impact both patient and practitioner alike. 

Learning more about accelerated risk in dentistry

To increase understanding of these issues, Dental Protection developed the Accelerated Risk webinar series, exploring the risks of accelerated treatment in orthodontics, implants, endodontics and indirect restorations. Members can access these through the Learning Hub.

webinar banner watch now